Skip to content.

Colour
  • Colour option 1
  • Colour option 2
  • Colour option 3

Document Actions

Hearing the wrong voices

The current welfare reform activity means that disabled people are as much as in the news as we've ever been but where, asks Tara Flood, are our actual voices in all this coverage

BBC broadcasting houseI was listening to an interview on the radio the other day – it was part of the ongoing debate about cuts to disability related benefits and featured the CEO of a large disability charity.

I couldn’t help but think why we still had to have a non-disabled person speaking on our behalf. Surely there are lots of disabled people who are more than up to doing this kind of thing – I could name a few of those people without giving much thought to it!

So what’s going on? Is it that the media remain too scared to speak to disabled people, or is it that the big charities are still keen to keep the limelight for themselves whilst promoting their “cool calm and collected” approach to our issues! Either way, our voices are silenced in one of the most important debates of our time.

The entire framework of services and benefits that support our lives are in danger of being dismantled.

Meanwhile a “cool calm collected” approach is hugely misrepresenting how terrified, angry and attacked we as disabled people are feeling about the Government’s slash & burn approach to disability benefits and services.

Where are all these big charity people when disabled people are protesting in their local communities? They are certainly not out on the streets where their support is needed – no – they are on the television and radio saying “how concerned disabled people are” – the understatement of the decade!!

This misrepresentation has got to stop. The big disability charities have got to recognise that when it comes to being an ally – actions speak louder than words.

When was the last time you saw a man speaking on behalf of a women’s rights group or a white person speaking for BAME communities? It just doesn’t happen anymore and it must not happen anymore for disabled people.

An inevitable consequence of non-disabled people continuing to speak about our lives and our “concerns” is that the media are let off the hook. Our invisibility in debates about our lives also means that Joe and Jane Public continue to believe that disabled people can’t speak up for ourselves.

How many times do disabled people have to shout “Nothing About Us Without Us” for the big charities to get the message? It could not be more clear, if the big charities want to be our allies they must stop speaking on our behalf.

Hearing the wrong voices

Posted by pam hill at 29 Jun 11 21:26
Luckily in Wales we have Disability Wales as both a campaigning and advice organisation. All their board members (and Chief Exec) are disabled themselves, as are the majority of their frontline workers. England obviously has to play catch-up with Wales for once.

get real

Posted by david smith at 14 Jan 12 10:05
I completely disagree. Why are (genuinely) disabled people so keen to protect the huge raft of hundreds of thousands of lazy work shy individuals who take advantage of liberal policies gone mad and do-gooders in the medical profession and civil service. Who can believe that 1 in 10 people are unfit for work? It is low wage earners and people in the pay as you earn trap who are the victims paying for all this and coming out with very little at the end of the day. Although most of us want to see a safety net can it be right that a disabled person has 2 or 3 times more disposable income than someone working full time? Added to the standard benefits and disability living allowance there is premium for severe disability, free dentist, housing benefit at a higher rate, free travel free prescriptions, cold weather payments oh and yes the £10 annual bonus. These huge social payments (when compared with job seekers allowance) may be justified if a persons disability was so severe that special care was needed but I suspect and have many personal examples where it is just being used as spending money. There is a huge number of people, mow masquerading under the umbrella of disability who should be either working or on job seekers, just as somebody who had actually contributed to all this for the last 25 years and made redundant, in these hard times . Yes £67.50 per week.

The disability system as it is with so many free loaders is bleeding the country dry. Please have regard that we are a socially minded people and take care of the truly needy. It is being paid for by the hard work of people who do not have a great deal themselves. As it is now 70 years on, we have a system that is being massively abused.